Nursing Home vs In-Home Care
Nursing homes provide 24/7 skilled medical care in a facility. In-home care brings caregivers to your home. The choice depends on medical complexity, care hours needed, and whether staying home is safe and practical.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Nursing Home | In-Home Care | |
|---|---|---|
| Location | Skilled nursing facility | Your own home |
| Medical Care | 24/7 RN care, complex treatments | Basic care; skilled nursing visits available |
| Coverage | 24/7 — never unsupervised | Scheduled hours only |
| Rehabilitation | On-site PT, OT, speech therapy | Home health visits for therapy |
| Social | Other residents, group activities | Existing social network |
| Avg Cost (AZ) | $7,908/month | $5,148/month (44 hrs/week) |
| Medicare | Short-term rehab (up to 100 days) | Skilled home health visits only |
| ALTCS | Yes, if qualified | Yes (HCBS waiver) |
Which Is Right for Your Family?
Choose Nursing Home if...
- Seniors needing 24/7 skilled nursing or medical monitoring
- Those recovering from surgery who need rehab
- People who can't be safely left alone at any time
Choose In-Home Care if...
- Seniors who strongly prefer staying home
- Those needing only a few hours of daily help
- Families with a primary caregiver who needs supplemental support
Pros and Cons
Nursing Home
Pros
- +24/7 medical care available
- +Medicare covers short-term rehab
- +Full rehabilitation on site
- +No gaps in coverage
Cons
- -Most expensive care option
- -Must leave home
- -Institutional environment
- -Less privacy and autonomy
In-Home Care
Pros
- +Stay in familiar home environment
- +One-on-one personalized care
- +Flexible scheduling
- +More autonomy
Cons
- -Gaps in coverage between shifts
- -Very expensive for 24/7 care ($16,000+/mo)
- -Still pay housing costs
- -Caregiver reliability varies
What This Means in Arizona
In Arizona, nursing homes cost $7,908/month while 44 hours/week of in-home care costs about $5,148/month. However, 24/7 in-home care would cost over $16,000/month. For seniors needing round-the-clock supervision, a nursing home is far more cost-effective.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is in-home care ever covered by Medicare?
Medicare covers skilled home health visits (nursing, therapy) if prescribed by a doctor, but does NOT cover personal care aides or companion care. Arizona's ALTCS Medicaid program can cover in-home personal care through the HCBS waiver.
Can my parent receive nursing-level care at home?
Partially. Skilled home health nurses can visit for specific medical tasks (wound care, injections, assessments), but they don't stay 24/7. For continuous skilled nursing, a nursing facility is typically necessary.
What about adult day care as a middle ground?
Adult day care in Arizona costs about $75/day and provides supervised activities and basic care during daytime hours. Combined with evening in-home care, it can be a cost-effective alternative to full-time nursing home placement.
Need Help Finding Care in Phoenix?
Our local advisors know every facility in Phoenix. Get personalized recommendations — completely free.
No cost. No obligation. Speak to a real person.
More Comparisons
- Assisted Living vs Nursing Home
- Assisted Living vs Memory Care
- Assisted Living vs Independent Living
- Assisted Living vs In-Home Care
- Memory Care vs Nursing Home
- Assisted Living vs Board and Care Home
- Independent Living vs Staying Home
- Respite Care vs Long-Term Care
- Adult Day Care vs Assisted Living
- CCRC vs Standalone Assisted Living
Not Sure Which Option Is Right?
Our local advisor will assess your loved one's needs and recommend the right type of care — completely free.